It has been a long time between studio albums in Liv Kristine’s solo career, with “River of Diamonds” arriving roughly 9 years after 2014’s “Vervain“. It is the longest release gap since her solo project began, and one has to question whether her professional and personal split with previous band Leaves’ Eyes and co-founder husband Alexander Krull in 2016 could have been a factor. Whatever the reason for the delay, we are grateful to once again see a new album from this pioneer of gothic metal.
Even more grateful that this album follows more in the tradition of Kristine’s early goth days, and less so – her foray into the realm of pop music. While it is true that “River of Diamonds” still has more in common with pop/rock than metal per se, it is easier to overlook this fact thanks to the darker vibe and more palatable song writing. On that note, it is worth mentioning that Kristine worked with Tommy Olsen (songwriter and old ex-Theatre of Tragedy bandmate) for each of the tracks on this record. And there are moments where they do an admirable job of paying tribute to their glory days.
This is especially true with the opening song “Our Immortal Day“, which features a duet with ex-Tristania vocalist Østen Bergø – whose deep baritone singing adds the sort of “Beauty and the Beast” staple dynamic that Kristine is known to have popularised. If it wasn’t for the overall softness, you could almost imagine you were listening to early Theatre of Tragedy. But instead, it is more comparable to something from an 80’s goth band like The Cure or Sisters of Mercy. “No Makeup” ditches the male vocals but maintains the romanticism in its lyrics.
The love that we do
Liv Kristine – No Makeup
Needs no makeup
Because it’s perfect
Ironically, this is followed up with “Maligna” which sounds more like a break-up song, and is rather shocking as I believe this is the first time I’ve ever heard Kristine swear (let alone drop the F-bomb). It raises questions again about whether some of these tracks are self-biographical, and inspired by some of the turmoil in Kristine’s life in the intervening years. The album proceeds with the minimalist “Gravity”, and this time the airy, high-pitched vocal delivery of Kristine is appropriately untethered and floating above the rest of the band. Whereas “In Your Blue Eyes” sees the guitar take a more prominent role, as it picks up the pace slightly, but ultimately drives forward what could be considered a somewhat saccharine mid-tempo number.
Then we are introduced to the title track “River of Diamonds“, and here Kristine drops all pre-tense of subtlety: “Undress me now // Open my soul // My desire is your desire // Hungry and pure“. The song also includes guest vocals from Frenando Ribeiro (Moonspell). But the most surprising guest on the album is perhaps reserved for the subsequent track “Pictured Within“, a Deep Purple cover which stars Kristine’s husband Michael Espenaes making his first ever debut as a vocalist. As the album proceeds, however, the initial excitement begins to fade, as that early Theatre of Tragedy sound becomes more and more difficult to hear. “Shaolin Me” and “Love Me High” make an effort to get us back to this point, but neither one succeeds entirely. The latter track is at least notable for its inclusion of Kristine’s sister Carmen Elise Espenaes (Savn, Midnattsol) on vocals. “Serenity” and “If I Am Dreaming” are much stronger compositions, as both satisfy that itch for something more traditional. But if you took this as an indication that perhaps the album would finish on a solid footing, you might be disappointed as the last track is a somewhat unnecessary cover of Cyndi Lauper’s “True Colours“. Nothing against the song or Kristine’s interpretation of it, but it simply feels a bit out of place (and not terribly goth).
There is no question that “River of Diamonds” has a number of great songs. But it’s not exactly the return to form that some may have hoped. There are glimpses of excellence, and nothing beats that early goth nostalgia hit, but the feeling is short-lived. It also lacks the heaviness that these songs are desperately crying out for, and while this doesn’t detract from the experience for the most part, it still makes it difficult to recommend this one to metal fans.
Verdict: River of Diamonds promises plenty for old-time fans, and while it does deliver on occasion, the album still falls short of past works. It remains a heartening attempt to return to the darker heritage of Liv Kristine’s music, but it’s one that is plagued by the lack of a harder sound, and an inconsistency in both quality and tone.
























